Posted on

Interview with Philippe Binard, general secretary of Freshfel Europe

Interview with Philippe Binard, general secretary of Freshfel Europe

1- What is your assessment of the impact of Covid-19 on the F&V sector?
During the pandemic, fruit and vegetables were considered as essential goods, which has facilitate seeking solution for border controls, and also seasonal workers. The increased F&V consumption observed since the Covid wave is demonstrating how strategic is our category, not only for our food supply but also for our health. The European consumers clearly understood they need to better feed themselves for a better health, and the F&V are contributing to it. In the peak of the pandemic, we estimate that the Covid impacted by more then €500 million per month the supply chain due to increased operational costs, more complex logistics operations, labor problems and added sanitary measures. The consumption and price levels increased, hopefully enough to off-set the increased costs and the loss of the food service demand. The seasonal spring campaigns like asparagus and berries were strongly affected, on a long run we hope the increased consumption will continue.

2- What is your position regarding the “Farm-to-Fork” program with the Commission?
Overall the Farm to Fork could move European citizens towards an healthier diet, which should be considered as a positive steps provided the right tools are put in place to reach this objective. In the farm to fork strategy there is however quiet a number of objective that will require careful attention to secure that they are feasible and coastwise realistic. Some targets, like a reduction of 50% in plant protection use and fertilizers, and a target of reaching 25% of organic agriculture farm land by 2030, might be difficult to reach. We see it as very ambitious and not closely enough related to the growth of demand for organic fresh produce. If the supply of EU organic produce goes far above the level of consumption it may lead to price drops, and the European producer will be the loser at the end. Our concept is to base the measures on the future of market demand, taken into account existing practice such as IPM rather then willing to impose a too ambitious sustainable policy.  

3- Which progresses regarding market access with non-EU countries this year?
A free-trade agreement with Vietnam just started from July 1rst but it is just a framework for more specific protocol agreements to be negotiated. The market is already opened for some varieties like citruses, apple, pears and potatoes. With Thailand various protocols were recently agreed for apple with several European countries. The EU is negotiating a free trade agreement with New Zealand and Australia, inclusive on customs duties, protections of origins and equivalences of the organic regulation, which could affect the F&V trade. With Japan no fruit shipments so far registered, due to a costly agreement for existing agreement such as Spanish citrus and French apples and many protocols are still pending and in negotiation for several years such as Italian kiwifruit.

4- Which next crop estimates from Northern or Southern Hemisphere?
We presented last May the predictions for the Southern Hemisphere citrus production while Northern Hemisphere citrus forecast will be relased by WCO (World Citrus Organization ) next October. In regard to apples and pears, this year Prognosfruit will be virtual and take place on 6th August (registration on for the Northern Hemisphere apple and pears estimates.

5- Which next step with the next reform of CMO related with F&V?
The existing program is postponed one more year until 2021, to give more time for the negotiations due to delays resulting from COVID and also the discussion on the Multi Financial Framework 2021-2027. The German presidency of the European Union will seek progress to accelerate the discussions and finalize concerted proposals by October of this year.

Posted on

Consumer satisfaction key to increasing tomato consumption

Worldwide production of tomatoes shows an upward trend, but the same can’t be said for per capita consumption of fresh produce

Worldwide production of tomatoes shows an upward trend, but the same can’t be said for per capita consumption of fresh produce.

According to Philippe Binard of Freshfel, the European fresh produce association, daily consumption in Europe is below the World Health Organisation recommendation of 400 g per capita. In what Freshfel calls an alarming trend, per capita daily EU consumption of fresh fruit and vegetables has decreased by 80 g – the equivalent of one piece of fruit – in the last decade.

And in the tomato category, the same trend is seen. Over the period 2004-13, average annual per capita consumption dropped 12 kg to sit at just above 9.5 kg – a decline of over 20% in 10 years. Yet at the same time, surveys show consumers overwhelmingly recognise that eating fruit and vegetables is one of the pillars of a healthy diet. (In a Eurobarometer poll, when asked what eating a healthy diet involves, 58% of respondents cited eating more fruit and vegetables.)

Speaking at the international conference ‘Tomatoes, trends towards 2020’ held in Antwerp in April, Binard said the many health benefits of eating fruit and vegetables – the production of which has a low impact on the environment – should therefore be emphasised more in communication with consumers. In that respect there also is pressure from NGO monitoring of pesticide issues but, “with a compliance rate of 99.1%, tomato production is extremely on the right track despite a negative image,” he said.

Current trends, such as vegetarianism, offer some opportunities in regards to increasing fresh produce consumption. The fact that more and more consumers are embracing a vegetarian or vegan lifestyle will likely lead to a higher intake of fresh fruit and vegetables: “A good development for the fresh produce sector,” Binard said.

Other consumers favour local, seasonal or organic products – all factors that can be harnessed in the marketing of tomatoes. “We fail to know the consumer,” Binard said, yet they should be the central focus in this process. He believes other sectors have a better picture of who their customer is and how to cater to their needs. External support can make a difference. More EU funding is available and the co-financing from the EU is moving from 50% to 80%, an improvement Binard considers likely to motivate more projects from the sector.

Tomato production growing faster than veggies overall

The popularity of tomato cultivation is increasing. Freshfel figures show production is growing very fast worldwide and has already reached over 130 million tons. Of the 44% rise in world vegetable production over 2000-13, nearly half of this derived from tomatoes.

Tomatoes also command a large share – 16% – of the fresh vegetable segment globally. Of the total global tomato production volume, about 88 million tons are destined for the fresh market and the remaining 42 million tons for processing. The top five global producers – China, the EU, India, the US and Turkey – together account for about 70% of production. The average annual EU tomato production of over 16 million tons – of which 41% is fresh tomatoes and 59% is processed – delivers 12% of global production.

The EU’s fresh vegetable production totals about 35 million tons, of which fresh tomatoes – which are the largest individual vegetable crop with a total of 6.8 million tons in 2014 – account for about 19%. About 7.8% of world tomato production takes place in the EU and while European fresh tomato production has seen some fluctuation, it been more or less stable over the past decade.

The volume of tomatoes destined for processing, however, was much more volatile over the period 2005-14, with a peak in production of nearly 11 million tons 2009 and a big dip in 2014 when the volume fell to under 8 million tons.

Just five EU member states are responsible for some 80% of EU tomato production: Spain, Italy, the Netherlands, France and Greece. While production has been rising in most EU countries since 2012 and overall European fresh tomato production is fairly steady, some countries have seen changes in terms of volume. In the past decade, production in Italy and Greece has declined, that of France has been more or less stable, and in the Netherlands and Spain, volumes increased over 2005-14.

On average, the ratio of fresh to processed tomatoes in the EU is about 40/60, but can vary widely within member states. For instance, the Netherlands and Belgium almost exclusively cater to the fresh tomato market, whereas in France and Spain the respective shares for the fresh market are 75% and 45% respectively. Major tomato grower Italy has a strong focus on the market for processed tomatoes, devoting just 18% of its production to supplying fresh tomatoes.

Exports under pressure, imports increasing

The tomatoes grown in Europe are predominantly consumed and sold within Europe. In 2014, intra-EU trade in fresh tomatoes amounted to 2.6 million tons with a value of €3 billion, meaning an average price of €1.13/kg. The top 5 EU destinations for fresh tomatoes are Germany, the UK, France, the Netherlands and Spain, according to Freshfel.

Last year, extra-EU exports of fresh tomatoes totalled 201,000 tons – worth €357 million – with an average price of €0.85/kg. Though exports to Belarus have partially replaced those to Russia, the impact of the Russian embargo has had a big impact on these exports, which have plunged 44% in volume in just two years after totalling 363,000 tons in 2013. The corresponding value fell from €435 million to €225 million, a decline of 48%. The top three non-EU markets for EU tomatoes are Belarus, Switzerland and Norway.

Imports of fresh tomatoes into the EU

Imports show an upward trend, having climbed 145% in 15 years to reach 487,000 tons in 2015, at an average price of €1.18/ kg for a total value of €415 million.

With a volume of 387,000 tons in 2015, Morocco is by far the EU’s largest fresh tomato supplier, having doubled its volume in the last decade. Next comes Turkey, which supplies around 50,000 tons to the EU. Up-and-coming import partners are African countries, such as Tunisia and Senegal, and new players from the Balkan region, such as Albania, Serbia and Macedonia.